Survival and prognostic factors in patients undergoing parenchymal saving bronchoplastic operation for primary lung cancer: a series of 110 consecutive cases.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to report our experience concerning bronchial sleeve lobectomy for treating bronchogenic cancer.

METHOD: From 1980 to 1994, 110 patients underwent bronchial sleeve lobectomy for bronchogenic cancer. In 45 patients, preoperative investigations contraindicated pneumonectomy, whereas in 65 other patients, sleeve resection was performed without functional necessity. The most common procedures were sleeve lobectomy of the right upper lobe (64%), and of the left upper lobe (21%). Sixteen patients (15%) underwent additional arterial vascular resection. Seven patients had microscopic invasion of the bronchial margin without the possibility of further resection in six with regard to their limited respiratory function. Tumors were staged as follow: 32 stage IB (all T2 N0), 57 stage IIB (57T2 N1), and 17 stage IIIA (eight, T3N1; nine, T2N2), whereas four patients had an in situ cancer (four stage 0).

RESULTS: Operative mortality was 2.75%. The 5- and 10-year actuarial survival rates were, respectively, 39 and 22% for the entire group. The 5-year actuarial survival rates were, 60% in stage IB, 30% in stage IIB, and 27% in stage IIIA. Four factors significantly influenced survival (P<0.05): nodal stage, arterial resection, invasion of the bronchial stump and poor functional respiratory status contraindicating pneumonectomy.

CONCLUSIONS: In our experience, sleeve resection for stage I provides comparable survival to that of standard resection at equal stage. However, in patients with pathologically N1 disease, who can tolerate a pneumonectomy, a randomized study is mandatory to confirm that sleeve lobectomy can be performed without the risk of decreasing long-term survival. In our study, patients who required an associated vascular resection demonstrated a poor survival.