Focal early stage cancer in ampullary adenoma: surgery or endoscopic papillectomy?

BACKGROUND: Recently, the evidence has been accumulating that endoscopic resection may be curative in treating ampullary adenoma that contains high-grade intraepithelial neoplasia/in situ tumor (HGIN/Tis). However, there are only anecdotal reports of endoscopic management of "focal" T1 ampullary cancer (T1 cancer), and radical surgery is still considered the only accepted treatment modality.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the possibility of endoscopic papillectomy as an alternative to radical surgery for the treatment of ampullary adenoma with HGIN/Tis or focal T1 cancer.

DESIGN: Retrospective evaluation of case series of our hospital from 1996 to 2006.

SETTING: Tertiary-care university teaching hospital.

PATIENTS: Twenty-three patients who had HGIN/Tis or focal T1 cancer in ampullary adenoma resected by endoscopic papillectomy and 60 patients who initially underwent radical surgery for HGIN/Tis or T1 cancer of the ampulla of Vater. "Focal" was defined as a lesion involving only mucosa, with a size less than a fourth the diameter of main adenoma.

INTERVENTIONS: Review of medical records and analysis of surgically or endoscopically resected specimens of ampullary tumors.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS: Locoregional extension and follow-up data.

RESULTS: Patients with HGIN/Tis of the ampulla of Vater had no lymphovascular invasion or lymph-node metastasis, and there were no occurrences of cancer or deaths during a mean (standard error [+/-SE]) 27.1 +/- 5.9 months after endoscopic papillectomy. T1 cancer was shown to have lymphovascular invasion and/or lymph-node metastasis in 10.7% and duct mucosal involvement in another 17.9%. Among them, patients with focal T1 cancer showed no lymphovascular invasion or lymph-node metastasis and no ductal involvement, and none of the patients who underwent endoscopic papillectomy alone had cancer recurrence or disease-related death for mean (+/-SE) 32.2 +/- 6.7 months.

LIMITATIONS: Single-center, retrospective study, small number of patients, and medium-term follow-up period.

CONCLUSIONS: Endoscopic papillectomy may be a curative treatment for ampullary adenoma with HGIN/Tis and should also be considered as an alternative to surgery in focal T1 cancer in ampullary adenoma.